Clinton’s emails and Liberals on Omar Khadr

2015 was a moving and happy year for Omar Khadr.
Our final 2015 write up about Clinton’s emails and the 2016 call of human rights groups to the new Liberal government.


Hillary Clinton’s end of 2015 released emails, from the time she was Secretary of State, disclose interesting exchanges on Omar Khadr. They reveal in particular Canada’s shameful role in frustrating Omar’s return to his country of origin.

Clinton had to intervene by reminding Baird, then Canada’s Minister of Foreign Affairs in Harper’s conservative Government, to honour the plea deal they had signed, allowing Omar to finally leave Guantanamo and return to his home country Canada. For 11 years, since age of 15, Canada had abandoned him.

After Clinton’s pressing demand Canada reluctantly repatriated him. There was delight in Clinton’s Office that Omar was being released from the detention center at Guantanamo Bay. Clinton’s emails show the joyful response to the news that the young man had finally been transferred to Canada.

2012 09 Hillary Clinton on Omar Khadr“Thank you for all you did to get this resolved,” then–Secretary of State Clinton wrote in an email to Koh, dated September 29, 2012.

“So glad we got this done,” Koh responded the following day. “After spending the last 10 years on GTMO, at least this young man finally has another chance.”

Every other Western nation had freed their civilians as soon they were repatriated from Guantanamo. In contrary, the Canadian Conservatives were determined to keep Omar behind bars as long as possible. They kept misinforming the public that Omar Khadr was convicted of serious offenses and labelled him as “a terrorist who was a threat to Canadian security”.

Monia Mazigh (International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group), questions in her article about Clinton’s emails: “why this vindictive attitude to prevent a child soldier from getting a “second chance”? Was Canada trying to please its US ally, even though they didn’t want Omar Khadr in Guantanamo prison anymore, or were they rather trying to please their political base and reinforcing their law and order agenda at the expense of Omar Khadr?”


With Omar’s release (on bail) on May 7, 2015 the Canadian public witnessed a decade of vilification by the Canadian government getting unravelled. During a remarkable press conference with Omar that same day, which attracted the world press, he was asked: “Do you have anything to say to Mr. Harper?” He answered, “Well I’m going to have to disappoint him, I’m better than the person he thinks I am.”

Now hopefully, with the Liberal victory in October 2015, an era has ended where governments brutally violate the rule of law for their own political gain.

Justin Trudeau said in 2014, he isn’t ruling out compensation for Omar Khadr for the time he was kept in Guantanamo Bay. “Omar Khadr needs to be treated the way we treat Canadians according to the rules that exist, according to the laws and principles that govern,” said Trudeau, adding that Omar should be treated like “any Canadian who as been incarcerated outside of the country.”

Faithful to his principles, Prime Minister Trudeau instructed the new Justice Minister, Jody Wilson-Raybould, to review the government’s overall legal strategy, including “early decisions to end appeals or positions that are not consistent with our commitments, the Charter or our values.”

This means that Ottawa will be reconsidering its position on Omar’s case and the Federal Liberals may not fight the ruling that released him on bail in May 2015.

With the law on his side, and the Liberal government’s promise to govern accordingly, 2016 will hopefully offer him the option that Hillary Clinton’s Office wished for him: “at least this young man finally has another chance”.

In the past half year, Omar has become a welcome member of the Edmonton community. He thoroughly enjoys life, is ambitious to make up for missed years of schooling and wants to be a productive contributor to Canadian society. He is also studying to be a medical first responder. His difficult journey inspired him to work in the medical field and be there for those in need.


Still Omar’s shameful case is not over and it is closely followed by critics globally and in Canada; “Omar Khadr” was number nine of all googled Canadian names in 2015.

The Canadian government should be held accountable for 13 years of abuse of Omar Khadr’s rights. Lawyers Rights Watch Canada (LRWC) and the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group (ICLMG) have written a joint report (Dec 21, 2015). They provide their views on the case of Omar Khadr for Canada’s Response to the List of Issues Prior to Reporting (LOIPR) from the UN Committee against Torture regarding compliance with the Convention against Torture.

The Federal Liberals will have much work to do to restore the high standing Canada once had in the field of human rights.


To bring an end to Omar’s ongoing ordeal, it would be prudent for the Canadian government to declare Omar a free citizen, provide him with redress, and hold accountable all government officials who contributed to the violation of Omar’s Charter Rights.




One comment on “Clinton’s emails and Liberals on Omar Khadr

  1. Okay, bit of a rookie here. Am all about Justice. A Canadian. Do not slide one by me though. Omar’s Canadian Lawyer is that way too but much smarter than I. I Must question the decisions of Omar’s parents initially. I think I heard Omar saying in the documentary they were trying to do anything possible to make humanitarian things work at the time the Afghan war broke out (paraphrase of course from a documentary I saw). However, as “Canadian” parents, you jeoprodized your children’s health and safety. Were you acting in the interests of Canadian children or Afghan war lords? Although all of us suck at decisions generally. In this article there seems to be a flagrant “brain cramp” miss of the fact the United States of America locked this young teenager down in the first place, within a military judicial system created with a perfectly unreasonable conundrum that would cause innocent and quilty to suffer equally; not fair equal justice for all. Canada got it wrong in many ways. So did the USA though. And so did a parent with a boy in a fight. Maybe all of them / us thought they were doing the right thing? In the end, instead of taking a moment to think about war, a young person was hung out to suffer immeasurably. We are all to blame. Separate faith and state always. No matter the consequence, allow a separate judicial system to look at the facts of a case and judge. Omar Khadr was not the problem or the solution in my humble opinion. Pick your fight with the proper bully in the schoolyard. Mike


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s